Self-Fulfilling Prophecy
Journal Title: ViraVerita: Peer-reviewed E-Journal of Interdisciplinary Encounters - Year 2019, Vol 9, Issue 0
Abstract
The distinction between science and pseudoscience and determining the criteria of scientificity are fundamental problems of the philosophy of science. At the point of determining the boundaries of science, important philosophers of science have tried to distinguish science from non-science by some criteria such as ‘’verifiability’’, ‘’falsifiability’’ and ‘’puzzle solving’’. However, many other criteria, which have been put forward together with the mentioned criteria, are inadequate to qualify some information as unscientific. This situation, which confirms the ambiguity of the science-non-science-boundary, is evident in the attitudes of today's scientists towards astrology. However, the current ‘’case of astrology’’ shows a great similarity with an ancient debate in terms of the point of departure and the nature of the criticisms being voiced. This ancient discussion, which can be called ‘’the case of prophecy’’, includes criticism of the Stoic prophecy which was thought to be a ‘’scientific’’ activity with certain principles, basics and formal rules, and the criticism of the authors who opposed to this understanding. The content of this study is to trace the problem of the boundaries of science based on the similarities between ‘’the case of astrology’’ and ‘’the case of prophecy’’ in the ancient times. In this paper, it is claimed that the boundaries of science cannot be drawn by some methodical criteria. To this end, firstly, the definitions and basics of the Stoics referring to the prophecy and the criticisms of the writers who are opposed to prophecy are discussed; and the position of “pseudoscience” is then evaluated based on these basics and criticisms. In the final analysis, this study tries to reveal that the criterion which distinguishes science from non-science is not methodical; it is rather based on the paradigms determined by social or political tendencies.
Authors and Affiliations
Melike Molacı
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP624699
- DOI -
- Views 86
- Downloads 0
Revolution Without Paradigm: An Evaluation On The Road Since Structure
In this study, the transformation of T. Kuhn's philosophy from The Structure of Scientific Revolutions to The Road Since Structure will be discussed. Although Kuhn's late works have a potential for rich discussion for ph...
Being a Syrian in Mardin: On Feeling at Home versus Exclusion from the City
In this paper, the impact of migration has been examined on a city scale. For this purpose, we have chosen Mardin, a city challenged by migration flows in the past and the present, as a case example. The similarity of Ma...
Culture in the Mirror of Language: Language – Culture Relationship in Humboldtian Philosophy
In this study, the relationship offered by Humboldt between culture and language will be examined. According to him, in addition to being constructed by language culture, constructs language as well. The identity of lang...
Securitization of Migration: Rising of Radical Right Wing Party 'AfD' in Germany and Syrian Refugee Crisis
Hosting the largest number of refugees in Europe, Germany has witnessed the strongest reactions against immigration. This study examines how the AfD, with the change of its party manifesto and leadership, has manipulated...
The Science Of Culture
KÜLTÜR veya MEDENİYET, en geniş etnografik anlamıyla alındığında, insanoğlunun2 toplumun bir mensubu olarak edindiği bilgi, inanç, sanat, töre, yasa, görenek ve diğer tüm yetenekler ile alışkanlıkların oluşturduğu karmaş...