Sovereignty of States and International Law Documents: Impressing or Impressed?
Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2013, Vol 7, Issue 2
Abstract
Sovereign States which originally were the sole actors in international society, in the course of the humanization of international law have been submitted to some commitments which are mostly of human rights nature. Such development faded out the role of sovereign States. This submission has been formed because of several factors. At the top of these factors emergence and development of human rights instruments is of high significance. On the other hand, application of these instruments and therein norms requires sovereign power which is essential for the execution of these instruments. This article focuses on this point and tried to answer this question that to what extent the human rights instruments have decreased the absolute sovereignty of States and on the other hand how and to what degree the existence and continuation of the power of States contribute to the realization of human rights norms. Stating the point that the human rights instruments could decrease the power of States, this article deals with the contribution of sovereignty to emergence and continuation and sanction of human rights norms. چکیده حاکمیتها در حقوق بینالمللی که روزی در جامعة بینالمللی یکهتاز بودند در سیر انسانی شدن حقوق بینالمللی تسلیم الزاماتی که عمدتاً حقوق بشری بودند، شدند و رفته رفته از نقش پر رنگ آنها کاسته شد. این انقیاد قدرت را در عوامل متعددی باید جستجو کرد که بر تارک آن قطعاً، ظهور و پیدایش اسناد حقوق بشری خودنمایی میکند. از طرف دیگر، جامة عمل پوشاندن به اسناد حقوق بشری و هنجارهای مندرج در آن، نیازمند قدرتی حاکمه است که توان اجرا و ضمانت بخشیدن به این هنجارها را داشته باشد. بنابراین، پاسخ به این پرسش هدف اصلی این مقاله را تشکیل میدهد که اسناد حقوق بشری تا چه میزان از حاکمیت مطلق دولتها کاستهاند و در طرف دیگر وجود و استمرار قدرت دولتها چگونه و به چه میزان به عینیت یافتن هنجارهای حقوق بشری کمک میکند. این مقاله، ضمن بیان این نکته که اسناد حقوق بشری توانستهاند از قدرت حکومتها بکاهند، به نقش حاکمیتها در پیدایش و نیز تداوم و ضمانت بخشیدن به هنجارهای حقوق بشری اشاره داشته و آنها را مورد بررسی قرار میدهد.
Authors and Affiliations
Heybatullah Najandi Manesh, Seyyed Ali Husseini Azad, Masoud Ahsan Nejad
Can Human Rights to Welfare Survive Without Religion?
Many contemporary authors fear that the proliferation of rights-claims may cause human rights to fall victim to their own popularity. If every good that is desired by one or another group of people is cloaked in the vene...
Religious Identity, Difference and Human Rights: the Crucial Role of Hermeneutics
Two fundamental questions tend to dominate religious discursive narratives and their interpretations: What duties and which rights are conferred by God applicable to all humans as the creation of God and regardless of th...
Human Rights and Human Cloning
Abstract Some opponents of human cloning regard it as wrong and unethical from a human rights perspective giving some reasons to prove their view. One is that each human being has the right to have his/her own human iden...
The Ethical and Legal Aspects of Fee Splitting in Healthcare
Imposing unnecessary medical and healthcare costs upon patients is in direct contrast with patient rights and the spiritual and historical values of medical practice and it seriously undermines the honor regarding doctor...
University Legal Clinics: Their Nature, Justification and Prospects
This article first introduces the university legal clinic as an independent, non-profit institution of public utility and as part of a university that simultaneously pursues two objectives: practical training of law stud...