THE DOCTORAL DEFENSE : DIVERSITY OF PRACTICES IN AMERICAN UNIVERSITIES
Journal Title: Academic Research International - Year 2013, Vol 4, Issue 6
Abstract
The doctoral defense is one of the most unique and pivotal events in the life of a young academic prior to launching a career in the university. And yet, there is very little information regarding the actual protocol of this defense experience and, where protocol exists, there seems not to be any nationally standardized formula for that process. In this study of twenty of the top Ph.D.-granting universities in the United States, I have described the various forms the doctoral defense takes, including (1) prerequisites to sitting for the defense such as residency, qualifying exams, languages, time factors, etc., (2) the composition of the defense panel itself, (3) who may, if any, be permitted to sit in the gallery or be present as silent observers and even non-faculty participants in the questioning of the defendant, (4) the time frame for the defense, (5) protocol in terms of questions, responses, etc., (6) who chairs the defense panel, and (7) the various levels of pass/fail permitted and employed by the panel, and tellingly, (8) may the defense be repeated in case of failure. The findings are both interesting because of the range of options operative within the American university system and startling due to the lack of either a standardized formula or a recognized protocol. Obviously, there is an opportunity here for discussion of the process.
Authors and Affiliations
John Morgan
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP147505
- DOI -
- Views 66
- Downloads 0
Implication of Sudra in Marriage Customary Law between Wangsa in Bali (Human Rights Perspective)
Indonesia is the thousand islands; Bali is one of those thousand islands. Bali is very rich in culture, customs, and traditions including the marriage customary law which still following the law at the time of colonizati...
PREDICTION OF THE SUITABILITY OF LOCATIONS FOR WIND FARMS USING FLEX EXPERT SYSTEM
Wind-generated electricity has the ability to provide electricity to homes and businesses withoutcausing air pollution or depleting non-renewable resources, unlike electricity generated by coal,natural gas, and oil (foss...
CREDIBILITY OF SCHOOL EXAMINATIONS IN ZIMBABWE: A REFLECTIVE ANALYSIS
It is certainly true that examinations play a major role both in assessment of learning and selectionof candidates for subsequent stages of education and/or for employment, (Bray 1998) hence mostcountries consider assess...
PEDAGOGICAL KNOWLEDGE OF RELIGIOUS EDUCATION TEACHERS IN BOTSWANA JUNIOR SRCONDARY SCHOOLS
Religious Education teacher trainees just like other teachers are expected to possess some knowledge that is linked to their classroom teaching upon completion of their teacher training. The teaching and l...
SEA RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN COMPLETING THE CONFLICT WABULA INDIGENOUS COMMUNITY BUTON REGENCY
Exploitation which is not accompanied by care or conservation will damage and make existing natural resources depleted even depleted. Therefore, the local government of Wabula Subdistrict launched a policy to improve an...