The ontological and moral significance of persons
Journal Title: Scientia et Fides - Year 2017, Vol 5, Issue 2
Abstract
Many debates in arenas such as bioethics turn on questions regarding the moral status of human beings at various stages of biological development or decline. It is often argued that a human being possesses a fundamental and inviolable moral status insofar as she is a “person”; yet, it is contested whether all or only human beings count as persons. Perhaps there are non-human person, and perhaps not every human being satisfies the definitional criteria for being a person. A further question, which will be the primary focus of this paper, concerns what essential features of personhood endow persons, human or otherwise, with their moral status and the inherent rights they concomitantly possess. A survey of the history of philosophical theorizing on what it means to be a person yields a broad consensus upon the key capacities being rational thought, self-consciousness, and autonomous volition. It is not sufficient, however, simply to cite these capacities, but to explain why these particular capacities bear moral import. A more recent concern has developed regarding the possible future existence of so-called “post-persons” who, due to their enhanced cognitive and emotive capacities, may be morally superior to mere persons and thereby possess a higher moral status. This paper will conclude with an analysis of the extent to which this concern is warranted.
Authors and Affiliations
Jason T. Eberl
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP327444
- DOI 10.12775/SetF.2017.016
- Views 74
- Downloads 0
After Suárez: Physical and Intentional Causality in the 17th-18th Centuries Scholasticism
The article investigates the distinction between the physical and the intentional causality that appeared in the 17th century scholasticism in the course of polemics with the traditional Aristotelian classification of ca...
Neurobiology and free will: a dialogue between Mariano Artigas and John Eccles
In this article, I discuss the importance of multidisciplinary research to tackle the questions that empirical sciences, and in particular neuroscience, ultimately encounter. The last decades have witnessed an enormous p...
The Ordinary is Extraordinary; The Wonder of the Mundane Physical World
Philip Kitcher and other secular naturalists assert that we have a problem-free concept of the "mundane physical world" and use the idea of our familiar material world to critique those who recognize a transcendent reali...
Oblicza religii Augusta Cieszkowskiego. Temporalny i dziejowy wymiar doświadczenia religijnego
Faces of Religion of August Cieszkowski. Temporal and Historical Dimension of Religious Experience August Cieszkowski is one of the greatest philosophers of Polish philosophy of nation and history. He was also a thinker...
Historiosophy of August Cieszkowski in the context of contemporary consciousness
Cieszkowski’s philosophy embodies the most influential trends in philosophy and culture of the nineteenth century. This does not mean, however, that Cieszkowski’s philosophy has today only historical character and it is...