The role and importance of dissenting opinion of judge of European Court of Human Rights
Journal Title: Альманах міжнародного права - Year 2016, Vol 13, Issue
Abstract
The article deals with the pressing questions of legal nature, role, signs, kinds and legal consequences of separate opinions of judges and to determination of concept and features of separate opinion of judge of European Court of Human Rights. On results research it is set: a) separate opinions of judges of European Court of Human Rights, expounded in concrete business, contain positions that differ from majority of judges that participated in voting opinion; b) in basis of disagreement with a decreet there can be other theoretical construction fixed in basis of argumentation and conclusions; c) appearance of separate opinions of judges of European Court of Human Rights is conditioned them by a scientific world view, as they are the representatives of the states with the different legal systems and legal traditions; d) expressing separate opinion a judge is unconnected the previous decisions of European Court of Human Rights; e) by a separate idea the judge of European Court of Human Rights can form new doctrine basis of decision; f) separate opinion of judge of European Court of Human Rights does not cause legal consequences, but can be interesting both for scientists and for practical workers and specialists in the different fields of law; g) separate opinion of judge of European Court of Human Rights can be the source of right an as such that generate law.
Authors and Affiliations
В. А. ЗАВГОРОДНІЙ
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP443541
- DOI -
- Views 62
- Downloads 0
Institute of the readmission of persons in the system of the public law
In the article scientific approaches related to a place of the readmission of per- sons in the legal system are researched. It is determined that dialectic of establishment and devel- opment of the readmission of persons...
The impact of the Monroe Doctrine on international law
This article explores the problem of the impact of the Political Monroe Doctrine on International Law. It shows the development of regional international law on American continent. The author given examples of regional a...
Practice of the European Court of human rights concerning violation of the right of confrontation and problemming of the implementation of article 6 (d) in Ukraine's criminal proceedings
The article deals with the problems of realization of pp. d p 3 p. 6 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms of 1950, incl. in the criminal proceedings of Ukraine. It is noted that t...
Financial sovereignty of the state as a subject of international financial law in the situation of economic globalization
The financial sovereignty of the state is an integral part of its internal sovereignty – the right to choose independently the model of the national financial system as well as external sovereignty – the right to establi...
International legal regulation of insurance relationships in the EU
The development of international relations and the world economy, processes of Ukraine’s entry and integration into the system of international economic relations cause a necessity to develop an insurance market taking...