The Scientology of Hypothesis Testing in Empirical Research: Emphasizing Economic Significance
Journal Title: American Journal of Economics and Business Innovation (AJEBI) - Year 2024, Vol 3, Issue 1
Abstract
Over the decades, scientists across various disciplines have cautioned against the practice of over-emphasizing statistical significance at the expense of economic or practical significance. It seems that empirical researchers in the 21st century have not heeded the caution because meeting statistical significance targets continue to take precedence over the wider discovery and publication of scientifically objective findings. Statistically insignificant results are rarely reported, in part due to publication bias towards statistically significant findings. The survey finds that although large sample sizes are widely used in empirical economics and finance research, none of the surveyed papers adopted alternative methods of hypothesis testing, such as Bayesian methods. All of them explicitly or implicitly used the classical Fisher’s hypothesis testing methods. This study finds that discussions on economic significance in nearly all papers (almost 97% of papers) only wrote one sentence or two regarding the magnitude of the effect of the regressors and a declaration that the findings were economically significant. We recommend that to enhance research credibility, other methods of hypothesis testing such as Bayesian methods, should be adopted. Journal article publishers should encourage the publication of statistically insignificant empirical findings. Economic or practical significance should be emphasized and comprehensively discussed.
Authors and Affiliations
Moses Mayondi, Richard Mulenga
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP731118
- DOI https://doi.org/10.54536/ajebi.v3i1.2349
- Views 53
- Downloads 0
The Role of Performance Budgeting in Developing Management Control in Universities: Evidence from Morocco
Under the combined effect of performance budget reforms and reforms of the higher education sector, universities face a set of constraints but also opportunities. More than ever, they are called upon to engage in strateg...
Future of Retailing in Metro Manila: DIY Homeowners’ Acceptance and Use of Technology in an Omnichannel Retailing
This paper investigates the multifaceted realm of consumer behavior within Metro Manila’s hardware industry, focusing on omnichannel factors that shape purchase intentions. Drawing from Venkatesh et al.’s 2003 Unified Th...
The Mediating Effect of Financial Self-Efficacy on Financial Behavior and Financial Well-Being of College Students in Region XI
A significant proportion of financial stress on students is often related to challenges like covering tuition fees, purchasing textbooks, and managing day-to-day expenses. This measures their ability to navigate financia...
Influence of High-Involvement and High-Commitment HRM Practices on Innovation: The Mediating Role of Knowledge Sharing
Given the important role of HRM practices and knowledge resources for firms to pursue innovation, the purpose of this study is to investigate the influence of high-involvement and high-commitment HRM practices on the inn...
The Fleeting Possibility of Merging the World’s Largest Chip Manufacturer in 2017: The Pain of Chinese Chip Industry
This article examines a possible Chinese semiconductor industry’s merger and acquisition in 2017, the year before the Sino-US trade war and US high-tech sanctions against China. The feasibility of a merger between Tsingh...