Theory of Needs as Justification of Human Rights: Current Approaches and Problems of Uncertainty and Normativeness
Journal Title: The Age of Human Rights Journal - Year 2018, Vol 10, Issue 10
Abstract
This paper deals with the theory of needs as a possible justification of human rights. First, it defines the concept of need, which differs from the concept of want. It states that need is, by definition, objective in nature. The paper then analyses some concepts of need (especially those of David Miller and Massimo Renzo) and examines their advantages and disadvantages in relation to justification theories (for example James Griffin's approach which is based on the idea of normative agency). According to the author, these concepts have natural-law foundations and cannot deal, in particular, with the problem of transition from facts to norms. In addition, the requirements that we usually derive from needs retain too much uncertainty. In spite of these shortcomings, using them as arguments in law and even more in politics retains a great convincing power. Its sources are difficult to identify, however, it is an important concept we use in everyday life (though in a shifted meaning). Finally, the author concludes that although needs are not able to establish human rights in a satisfactory way – provided we renounce the universal nature of these rights – they can play a very useful and important role in justifying them in certain local contexts.
Authors and Affiliations
Martin Hapla
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP694487
- DOI 10.17561/tahrj.n10.1
- Views 116
- Downloads 0
Insurgency, Counter-Insurgency and Human Rights Violations in Nigeria
Insurgents’ activities and government’s counter-insurgency operations have claimed hundreds of lives and destroyed many human habitations and sources of livelihoods across Nigeria. Essentially, the rising wave of insurge...
The Challenge of the Cultural Diversity in Mexico Through the Official Recognition of Legal Pluralism
This article explains the factual situation of the recognition of Legal Pluralism in Mexico, the way it has been handled out in a formal way and how Diversity has become a challenge in Mexico. Cultural rights are in a pr...
Disability and Humans Rights: A Theoretical Analysis
Since Enlightenment, theories of justice and, in particular, theories of human rights have been based on principles which are excludable for people with disabilities. The exclusion has not been resolved by contemporary t...
Bentham Was Right. Was He?
The importance that the majority principle occupies in Bentham’s theory reveals how it was in tune with what others thought about this principle. I will discuss only the role that this principle holds in Kelsen. For him,...
The Crisis of State Sovereignty and Social Rights
The European integration process –which may be interpreted as a federalizing process– faces strong cultural and economic resistances. As a matter of fact, social rights have been understood and performed –within an old t...