THIRD-PARTY QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AUDITS: PERCEPTIONS, LIMITATIONS AND RECOMMENDED IMPROVEMENTS

Journal Title: Quality Issues and Insightsin the 21st Century - Year 2013, Vol 2, Issue 1

Abstract

Third-party quality audits have been a continued practice within the manufacturing community since release of the ISO 9000 standard in 1987. In recent times, many within the manufacturing industry are questioning the value of the audit process. (Sayle, 1995, Sayle 1999, Douglas, 2000, Gordon, 2001, Dalgleish 2006) Consequently, a need exists to better understand the impacts and perceptions of the third-party auditing process. This research used a grounded theory approach to explore the following question: How do management representatives perceive the third-party audit process? Collection of data consisted of 25 in-depth interviews taken from management representatives within the North American automotive industry. Job titles of research participants included Quality Director, Quality Manager, and Quality Engineer. Results of the research include (a) the third-party audit process is adequate to assess an organization’s quality management system against the ISO/TS16949 standard, (b) the third-party audit process fails to add tangible value for the organization, (c) the relationship between the auditor (registrar) and auditee (organization) represents a significant conflict of interest, (d) the continued audit cycle is redundant and offers diminishing value, and (e) mature organizations fail to benefit from the third-party audit process. Results substantiate the views offered by Sayle (1995 & 1999), Douglas (2000), Gordon (2001), Karapetrovic and Willborn (2002), Beckmerhagen, Berg, Karapetrovic, and Willborn (2004), and Dalgleish (2006). Furthermore, a final model is offered to depict the fundamental changes recommended to improve the audit process. The conclusions of the research include: (a) Revise the ISO/TS standard to incorporate requirements that drive continual improvement and offer value to an organization, (b) Develop ISO registration and audit process infrastructure whereby the organization does not have leverage over the auditor and make the audits truly third party, (c) Remove the requirement for continued audit cycles for organizations that have periodically demonstrated compliance to requirements via surveillance audits. Eliminate the requirement for continued audit cycles, and (d) Incorporate assessment of the quality management system level of maturity as a method to determine if an organization is in need of a third-party audit. This study suggests that, by and large, tangible value is not a benefit of the third-party audit process. Consequently, as a value added activity, or a continual improvement tool, the third-party audit process is ineffective, insufficient and in need of significant changes Suggestions for further research include (a) conducting a quantitative study to demonstrate the financial impact of the third-party audit process; (b) determining if an organization’s quality and customer performance improves over time after becoming ISO/TS certified; (c) conducting a quantitative study of management representatives within the automotive community to determine the percentage that support third-party audit process; (d) completing a case study on a successful, profitable non-ISO-certified manufacturing organization; (e) conducting a Delphi study on the Kluse Utopian Third-Party Audit Model; and (f) investigating alternatives to the audit process as a method to determine QMS compliance and effectiveness. Additionally a future researcher may seek to understand how factors such as human resources practices, organizational climate and knowledge management affect an organizations quality-related performance.

Authors and Affiliations

Christopher Kluse

Keywords

Related Articles

SOME EDUCATION QUALITY MANAGEMENT SKETCHES

It wouldn’t be right to say that quality management questions in Lithuania are perfectly known, analysed and there’s nothing to do in this sphere. On the contrary, this sphere remains very urgent, on the other hand, rath...

EFFICIENT MANAGEMENT AND MANAGER’S PERSONALITY

Some standards of quality management are enumerated that are focused on the process of detecting and capturing the defects, meeting the technical requirements, as well as satisfying the customers and the employees. Some...

ADULT EDUCATION: A PATH TO SOCIAL INCLUSION. A CASE STUDY IN MOLISE (ITALY)

The society needs to rediscover education as a means for social inclusion. One of the most difficult challenges, at this respect, is to define the social inclusion of marginalized groups (the unemployed, the elderly, the...

UNIVERSITIES AND COMPANIES STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP: RUSSIAN PRACTICE

One of the main purposes of the educational system is to provide a qualified workforce for the companies of the different industries. And nowadays universities understand that along with the teaching and research activit...

QUALITY OF PROCESSING AND TRANSMITTING WRITTEN INFORMATION CONTAINING VERBAL ILLUSIONS IN YOUTH AGE

There are some different standards for quality of processing and transmitting of information. This study compared three quality standards of transmission of verbal written information. One quality standard is keeping ini...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP454424
  • DOI -
  • Views 124
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Christopher Kluse (2013). THIRD-PARTY QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AUDITS: PERCEPTIONS, LIMITATIONS AND RECOMMENDED IMPROVEMENTS. Quality Issues and Insightsin the 21st Century, 2(1), 28-45. https://europub.co.uk/articles/-A-454424