TOOL USE IN A PSYCHOMOTOR TASK: THE ROLE OF TOOL AND LEARNER VARIABLES
Journal Title: International Journal of Instruction - Year 2011, Vol 4, Issue 2
Abstract
Research on the use of learning tools has brought to light variables that influence the learner on using or not using the tools. A deeper analysis on the current findings is attempted in this study. It adds a psychomotor task; it assesses the actual functionality of the employed tools, and it further explores learner-related variables that influence tool use, most importantly on perceived tool functionality (the beliefs of learners that a certain tool would be the most optimal one). Fifty-eight learners had to build a LEGO® figure. Two tools were used: a video with intentionally low functionality demonstrating the figure assembly, and a step-by-step guideline with pictures. Based on the tools, there were three experimental conditions: guideline (G), video (V) both tools (GV); and one control condition (C) without tools. To analyze the functionality of the tools, the effect of tool use on performance was monitored at two different moments in all conditions. To examine the perceived functionality of tools, the tool use by the learners was monitored in the (GV) condition. Moreover, we checked for the effect of prior knowledge, metacognition and self-efficacy on tool use in the (GV)condition. Results revealed that the tools were functional. The (G), (V) and (GV) conditions significantly outperformed the (C) condition, but contrary to our assumptions, the (V) condition outperformed the other experimental conditions. Regarding perceived functionality, all learners perceived the tools as functional, that means all learners picked a tool. They, however, could not identify from which tool they would benefit the most, i.e. they could not recognize the most functional tool. Concerning the other learner-related variables, no significant effect was found. Theoretical implications for further research are discussed. First on what kind of tool-related variables influence tool use. Second on the effect learner-related variables, especially perceptions, might have on using tools.
Authors and Affiliations
Norma A. Juarez-Collazo, Griet Lust, Jan Elen, Geraldine Clarebout
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP134666
- DOI -
- Views 101
- Downloads 0
Digital Discourse Markers in an ESL Learning Setting: The Case of Socialisation Forums
Analysis of the linguistic discourse plays an important role in the social, cultural, ethnographic, and comparative studies of languages. Discourse markers as indispensable parts of this analysis are reportedly more co...
Pedagogic Effectiveness of Print, Interactive Multimedia, and Online Resources: A Case Study of IGNOU
In the present paper, the authors report on a comparative study on the pedagogic effectiveness of printed self-learning text with face-to-face tutorial support, interactive multimedia CD-ROM and online learning in...
An Evaluation of the Undergraduate TEFL Program in Iran: A MultiCase Study
The purpose of this study is to assess the quality of Islamic Azad University TEFL program at B.A. (undergraduate) level in Iran. To do so, five IAU branches were selected through cluster sampling. Within each branch s...
L’Évaluation des Croyance et les Pratiques des Enseignants de Langues dans l’Enseignement Primaire
L’utilisation de l’évaluation, le procesuss de collecte d’informations en réusite et en performance de létudiant,a été prôné depuis longtemps pour les cycles d’apprentissage peut être planifié ; l’instruction peur...
Application d'un Modèle d'Apprentissage Résultant de l'expérience à l'Enseignement de Jeux de Société de Stratégie de Passerelle
Le passe-temps de jeu de société a rapidement cultivé et s'est développé ces dernières années, mais les bouts de manque de jeux les plus non-numériques et des classes de travaux dirigés et reste difficile d'apprendre e...