Twenty aspects of emptiness in Prajnaparamita Buddhism
Journal Title: ИДЕИ. ФИЛОСОФСКО СПИСАНИЕ - Year 2015, Vol 3, Issue 1
Abstract
This article examines the canonical list of “twenty kinds of emptiness (śūnyatā)” in рrajñāpāramitā Buddhism. The meaning of every one of them is determined by the means of comparative analysis of the texts of Chinese Buddhist canon (Chinese versions of prajñāpāramitāsūtra, Vasubandhu, Nāgārjuna and a treatise of a later Tiantai thinker Zhi-yi). All the basic variants of Chinese terms used by the Chinese Buddhists in the process of translation from Sanskrit are listed together and their different semantic variations are analyzed. In spite of the fact that the most popular was the expression “twenty emptinesses” there are lists of fourteen, sixteen, eighteen positions, and Chinese Buddhists considered the list of “eighteen emptinesses” to be the most basic one. This may support a suggestion made by researchers concerning later origin of the list with twenty positions. Besides this, the order of positions in the list in different sources is not identical. This is often due to the efforts of the Buddhist authors to find in this list a logical succession based mostly on gnoseological approach (emptiness of subject of perception, emptiness of object of perception etc.). But independently of differences in the lists of “kinds of emptiness” and different variants of their translation and interpretation in the Buddhist tradition, the emptiness is only one – śūnyatā, serving all the different lists of “emptinesses” merely to make easier the perception of the ideas of śūnya-vādaas an example of applying the principle of emptiness (illusiveness, unreality) to different groups of objects. Therefore it is more correct to speak rather about twenty aspects of emptiness, than about twenty kinds of it.
Authors and Affiliations
Anastasia Strelkova
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP297818
- DOI -
- Views 124
- Downloads 2
Allocution of academic Popovich towards readers and admirers Journal "IDEAS: a philosophical description"
Уважаемые и дорогие наши болгарские друзья! Обращаясь к вам накануне ХХIII Всемирного философского конг-ресса «Философия как исследование и образ жизни», который состоится 4-10 августа этого года в славно...
Paradox and existential method in the interpretation of Howard Slaatte
The problem of the relation of existentialism and theology in the work of Howard Alexander is drain. Focused on the issue of inclusion of existentialist methodology in contemporary Christian theology, to study the concep...
Protestantism existentialist modernization in Paul Tillich’s theology
The article analyzes the methodological problem of the application of Paul Tillih’s existentialist categorial-conceptual apparatus to update the theological interpretation of Christian proclamation today. We c...
The phenomenon of love in the Ancient philosophical tradition: on the rethinking of the theoretical basis of research
The article analyzes theoretical basis of the study of comprehension of love in the Ancient philosophical thought. The necessity to involve different kinds of scientific research on ancient philosophy is proved. This mak...
Alteration of conventional notion of Rationality and Science in Catholic Modernism (exemplified by concept of Havryil Kostelnyk)
The article highlights the figure of the Ukrainian philosopher and theologian Havryil Kostelnyk as a representative of Catholic Modernism. The controversial nature of Kostelnyk’s views on science and rationality is analy...