When does a man beget a monster? (Aristotle, "De Gneratione animalium")
Journal Title: Collectanea Philologica - Year 2016, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
In this paper I discuss the problem of the borderline between the lack of resemblance to any family member and monstrosity in Aristotle’s "Generation of Animals". In book IV both phenomena have been explained as a result of ‘resolution’ or ‘loosening’ of the‘movements’ in the sperm, whose function is to recreate in the offspring’s body the features of its parents or ancestors. Consequently, sometimes the offspring bears no resemblance to any ancestor, and sometimes ‘it no longer has the appearance of a human being at all’. According to T. V. Upton, both groups are ‘monsters’ of some kind; he names them ‘generic individuals’, assuming that after ‘loosening’ of the movements which carry particular traits, the task of completing the embryo’s development is taken by the movements of universals (genus or species) present in the sperm. In contrast to Upton’s opinion, I try to prove that the movements of particular – although ‘merged’ and changed – still remain active, leading to the final development of any given individual; in the case of a ‘monster’, however, a deformation of the offspring’s whole body or its parts results not only in the lack of resemblance to any representatives of its own species, but also in disability.
Authors and Affiliations
Joanna Sowa
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP199419
- DOI 10.18778/1733-0319.19.01
- Views 70
- Downloads 0
Internacjonalny charakter łacińskiej terminologii elektronicznej
The article deals with the possibilities of the Latin language usage as a means of communication in the modern world. It is an analysis leading to answering the question about Latin’s inherent possibilities for passing t...
Recenzja książki: Grzegorz Kotłowski i Elżbieta Starek "Łacińskie inskrypcje w kościołach Gdańska. Bazylika mariacka", wyd. Bernardinum, Pelplin 2013, ss. 105.
The Authors, Grzegorz Kotłowski and Elżbieta Starek, present 31 Latin inscriptions with added photographs and give their Polish translation. These inscriptions, mostly of the seventeenth century, are preserved in the Baz...
Obraz niedoli w pieśni weselnej, czyli epitalamia Drakoncjusza jako przykład jego nowatorstwa
In this paper I examine Dracontius’ distinctiveness from other Latin and Greek poets writing epithalamia. He is not just another author of original wedding songs but surprises in many ways and can be found unusual even e...
Obraz miłości małżeńskiej w eklodze "Acon" Giovanniego Pontana
Acon is one of the six eclogues written by Giovanni Pontano, one of the most remarkable humanists of the Italian Quattrocento. In this work, the author presents an image of conjugal love by the usage of a bucolic context...
La poesia di Giovanni Pietro Arrivabene
With this brief study, first the author deals with the poetry by Giovanni Pietro Arrivabene. In fact, for the first time he has published a long Latin poem of the poet preserved in a single manuscript in Pienza, in the l...