When does a man beget a monster? (Aristotle, "De Gneratione animalium")
Journal Title: Collectanea Philologica - Year 2016, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
In this paper I discuss the problem of the borderline between the lack of resemblance to any family member and monstrosity in Aristotle’s "Generation of Animals". In book IV both phenomena have been explained as a result of ‘resolution’ or ‘loosening’ of the‘movements’ in the sperm, whose function is to recreate in the offspring’s body the features of its parents or ancestors. Consequently, sometimes the offspring bears no resemblance to any ancestor, and sometimes ‘it no longer has the appearance of a human being at all’. According to T. V. Upton, both groups are ‘monsters’ of some kind; he names them ‘generic individuals’, assuming that after ‘loosening’ of the movements which carry particular traits, the task of completing the embryo’s development is taken by the movements of universals (genus or species) present in the sperm. In contrast to Upton’s opinion, I try to prove that the movements of particular – although ‘merged’ and changed – still remain active, leading to the final development of any given individual; in the case of a ‘monster’, however, a deformation of the offspring’s whole body or its parts results not only in the lack of resemblance to any representatives of its own species, but also in disability.
Authors and Affiliations
Joanna Sowa
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP199419
- DOI 10.18778/1733-0319.19.01
- Views 84
- Downloads 0
APOSTROFY DO WÓD – NOWE SPOJRZENIE NA CYKL EPIGRAMÓW W CZWARTEJ KSIĘDZE MARCJALISA (18, 22 I 63)
The article focuses on the Martial’s poems no. 18, 22 and 63 from the Book 4 of epigrams. These poems unite in a cycle of epigrams with a common motif of an apostrophe to water appearing in the last line of each epigram....
Za głosem Penelopy
"Following the voice of Penelope" is the review of a play based on one of the Homer’s greatest epic poem – Odyssey, staged by Ondrej Spišák in the Warsaw puppet theatre „Teatr Lalka”. This artistically beautiful, full of...
Historia leksykonu "De verborum significatu"
The Lexicon of Verrius Flaccus (De verborum significatu) is the first Latin dictionary which included a lot of information about the history, society, religion and topography of Rome. Unfortunately, it is only known in f...
Pindaric Kleos
This article discusses the issue of how kleos works in Pindar’s epinician odes. Firstly, it deals with the relationship between Pindaric and epic, and specifically, Homeric kleos. It tries to answer the question why Pind...
The Political Involvement of Myth in Its Stage Adapatations
Ancient myths from the Mediterranean Culture often become a language used to express current social and political anxieties. In the contemporary theatre ancient myths are deconstructed and subverted according to the post...