A Legal-Judicial Deliberation on the Article 575 of the Civil Law
Journal Title: فقه و اصول - Year 2011, Vol 43, Issue 87
Abstract
Although in principle the benefit and loss resulted from partnership is to be taken into consideration in private relationships proportionate to the parties’ shares, prediction of stipulating more benefit or exempting all or part of the loss in the company’s contracts, with respect to the existing necessities and the need for maximum participation, is a common practice. Whereas, the article 575 of the civil law apparently does not approve all these stipulations; rather, on the contrary, it signifies the invalidity of the condition of surplus benefit without extra action and the condition of greater loss for some of the partners. That is why it is necessary to reappraise and critically review the discursive principles of article 575 in order to better understand it. In this respect, through studying various legal and judicial dimensions of the issue in question and close examination of the principles presented by the jurists and legal experts, it can be concluded that there has been no barrier for approving the above-mentioned stipulations and that it behooves the legislator to provide for the possibility of predicting the stipulation of more benefit without its conflict with action and the possibility of stipulating greater loss.
Authors and Affiliations
Sayyid MuḥAmmad Taqī QabūLī DurafshāN, Sa‘īD MuḥSinī
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP183254
- DOI 10.22067/fiqh.v0i0.11097
- Views 128
- Downloads 0
A jurisprudential and legal research into the oath of knowledge denial
Among the topics discussed in books of jurisprudence is denial of knowledge, which is considered as a subdivision of taking oath based on issue. Regardless of the originality of oath on denying knowledge, substantial dis...
Reappraisal of Renunciation of Ownership in Jurisprudence and Law
The issue of renunciation (i‘rāḍ) is not discussed separately among the jurists and is only implicitly referred to in some instances. It is also neglected in statutes; and most of legal experts, following the laws and li...
A Glance at the Impact of Invalid Conditions on a Contract
Although the corrupted condition is not protected by sanctions, there are three beliefs as to whether its corruption (fasād) permeates the contract (‘aqd) or not: theory of fasād, theory of non-permeation of fasād, theor...
Shī‘ī Versified Jurisprudence in the Last two Centuries
One of the methods of the past scholars for better and faster learning of sciences has been the versification of scientific material. This type of poetry is called ta‘līmī (didactic) in technical terms. Many scholarly ma...
A Deliberation on Punishment for Pederasty: Legal-Judicial Analysis of Article 110 of Iranian Civil Law
Despite the challenges noticed in the meaning and concept of pederasty (lawāṭ), different viewpoints have always existed among the jurists concerning the punishment of the pederast, to the extent that some jurists have d...