Ahlussunnah and Syi’ah’s Views on the Hadis Ahl al-Bayt: The Prophetic tradition (Kitâballâhi wa ‘itraty…)
Journal Title: MIQOT: Jurnal Ilmu-ilmu Keislaman - Year 2013, Vol 0, Issue 1
Abstract
Abstract: Ahlussunnah and Syi’ah’s Views on the Hadis Ahl al-Bayt. The Prophetic tradition (kitâballâhi wa ‘itraty…) is one of the most debated hadiths amongst the two mainstreams Islam: Ahl Sunnah dan Syi`ah. This paper tries to elucidate the understanding of both sects on Ahl al-Bayt by referring to the chain of transmitters of this hadith while explaining the quality of the Quanic and Tradition arguments as s support for their opinion. The witer comes to the conclusion that, for the Syi’ah this hadith is perceived as reliable and thus it becomes the bases for their doctrine of Ahl al-Bayt. They also confine the Prophet family to only Ali, Fathimah, Hasan and Husein. For Ahl Sunnah, however, they hold that such hadith is unreliable due to its weak transmitter, although some of them accept it with the availability of other lines of transmitters and thus imply in their understanding of Ahl al-Bayt which is not only limited to the four mentioned figures.
Authors and Affiliations
Daud Rasyid
ETIKA ISLAM DALAM RANAH POLITIK: Respon dan Tinjauan Kritis Nahdlatul Ulama dan Muhammadiyah Provinsi Jambi terhadap Penyelenggaraan Pilkada Langsung, 2005-2015
Islamic Ethics in the Realm of Politics: Response and Critical Review of Nahdlatul Ulama and Muhammadiyah of Jambi Province Against the Implementation of Direct Elections (2005-2015). This paper reviews the impacts of el...
HUMAN REALITY AND PERFECTION IN THE PHILOSOPHICAL VIEW OF SUTAN TAKDIR ALISJAHBANA
Abstract: This article focuses on Sutan Takdir Alisjahbana’s thoughts on the philosophy of man and its relevance to contemporary Islamic thought. This study used Eduard Sprenger’s theory of six basic values of philosophy...
PAKIAH AND SADAKAH: The Phenomenon of Mamakiah Tradition in Padang Pariaman
This article reveals the phenomenon of mamakiah in pakiah community, students of traditional Islamic boarding school (pesantren) Padang Pariaman. Niimma claims that sadakah obtained by pakiah in some pesantren, submitted...
GERAKAN ISLAMIS DI SUMATERA BARAT PASCA ORDE BARU
Abstract: Islamist Movement in the Post-New Order Era West Sumatra. Islamist movement or radicalism emerges not only due to the literal understanding of verses of the Qur’an nor is it political, social and economic fact...
SPIRITUALITAS SAINS DALAM ISLAM: MENGUNGKAP TEOLOGI SAINTIFIK ISLAM
Abstrak: Artikel ini membahas pemikiran Islam tentang teologi saintifik yang sering menjadi perdebatan para ilmuwan. Sebagian pakar berpendapat bahwa al-Qur’an memotivasi umatnya untuk mencintai sains. Pakar lain berpan...