Air Pollution, Health and Ethics
Journal Title: Annals of Bioethics & Clinical Applications - Year 2018, Vol 1, Issue 1
Abstract
Recent findings about nitrogen dioxide pollution in Britain and about particulate pollution worldwide raise ethical issues about the protection of human (and animal) health. Many urban areas of Britain have been found to have illegally high levels of NO2. But it turns out that there is a world-wide problem with particulates, particularly in large towns and cities in Third world countries, as well as in much of Europe and North America. In many cases diesel engines are to blame, and these should be phased out as soon as possible. In other cases the source is to be found in unregulated industrial expansion, or in dust-storms from recently expanding deserts. Remedies thus include reafforestation, the preservation or restoration of wetlands, and moves away from carbon-based electricity generation to generation from renewables, and from internal combustion engines to electric cars. The ethical case for saving people from nitrogen dioxide and particulate pollution turns out importantly to overlap with that for greenhouse gas mitigation. Chris McMahon pointed out to me on 14/12/17 that what is crucial is to abandon internal combustion engines. Abandoning diesel engines will enhance health in the present, but make, on average, only a few weeks difference to life expectancy if petrol engines are used instead. Besides, most trucks and ships are propelled by diesel, and these need to be considered too. (The environs of ports and large airfields are very dangerous for those who live there; so are large cities such as Delhi and Mexico City.) Introducing electric cars does little good if the batteries are charged with carbon generated electricity. We need to generate electricity from renewables, and yet to do this at a sufficient scale would require devoting some 15% of non-renewable energy to the production of renewable-generation technology. Nuclear fusion would solve the problems, but is not likely to be available in the foreseeable future. Each form of fuel needs to be considered in the round and from cradle to grave.
Authors and Affiliations
Attfield R*
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP745128
- DOI 10.23880/abca-16000103
- Views 30
- Downloads 0
Bioethics and Human Rights: The Genomic Editing Technique Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeat (CRISPR-CAS9) and the Contemporary Biotechnological Challenges
This article deals with biotechnological advances, especially in the field of editing and genetic engineering. In contemporary times, the possibility of manipulating the human genetic heritage and creating perfect organi...
Actions by the Brazilian Government Regarding Elderlies’ Conditions in Times of COVID-19
Brazil, as well as other countries, is facing a health crisis due to the pandemic of Covid-19. In this context, many lives have been cut short because of entanglements of the contagion. Among people that have been contam...
Contrast between the Foreign Policy of President Enrique Pena Nieto and President Andrés Manuel Lopez Obrador
The objective of this research is to make a comparison with respect to the objectives of foreign policy in his first three years of President Enrique Peña Nieto and his counterpart Manuel Andrés Lopez Obrador, as well as...
Ethics of Healthcare Personnel Declining Covid Vaccine Is it Ethical for Healthcare Professionals to Decline the Covid19 Vaccine if it is Available?
I recently had a student pose this question to me after class (virtually). It did not take me long to answer, my response was “only in very limited circumstances”. Allow me to explain why. When I think of healthcare ethi...
Why Disinformation Works. How Otherwise Reasonable People can Ignore Facts and Believe Purposeful Mistruths. What Next?
I’m writing today to offer what has become an annual update in these pages to growing concerns about misinformation, disinformation and the harm they cause to individuals and the public health. I’ll review those concerns...