Brak możliwości uznania orzeczenia zagranicznego sądu powszechnego oddalającego skargę o uchylenie wyroku sądu polubownego – glosa do postanowienia Sądu Najwyższego z 6.11.2009 r.
Journal Title: ADR. Arbitraż i Mediacja - Year 2018, Vol 4, Issue 44
Abstract
The Supreme Court issued a decree which states that a verdict of a foreign court which removes a petition for the reversal of an award of a court of arbitration is not liable for recognition based on the article 1145 § 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The gloss discusses the verdict of the Supreme Court in a wider context of a worldwide discussion in regard to possibility of accepting foreign verdicts of common courts of law which reverse an award of a court of arbitration (so-called awarding judgment). In the author’s opinion, the Supreme Court accurately – in defiance of a dominating tendency in judicature of other countries – rejects a possibility of a privileged creditor to use awarding judgment. Moreover, settling of the Supreme Court has a wider meaning. It seems to result in not recognizing foreign verdicts of which the subject is recognition or affirmation of executability of an arbitration order. The accepted standpoint limits a possibility to use techniques, such as forum shopping and excessive harassment of a debtor. It also supports autonomy of arbitration orders by making them separate from evaluation made by court of the place of arbitration. Evaluation whether certain arbitration order qualifies to recognition or execution should be up to a court from the country of recognition or execution. There are no reasons for that court to be constricted with previous rulings of courts where the arbitration took place.
Authors and Affiliations
Maciej Zachariasiewicz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP544157
- DOI -
- Views 33
- Downloads 0
Zastosowanie alternatywnych metod rozwiązywania sporów w sprawach dotyczących zdarzeń medycznych
The usage of alternative dispute methods in cases of medical events The article addresses the topic of innovative usage of alternative dispute methods which is applied in cases of medical events. In chapter 13a of 6 Nove...
Charakter prawny ugody zawartej przed mediatorem w postępowaniu karnym.
The article discusses one of the alternative dispute resolution-mediation institutions. The purpose of this article is to determine the legal nature of a settlement concluded before a mediator in criminal proceedings. Th...
Dopuszczalność stosowania instytucji kadłubowych zespołów orzekających – uwagi na tle polskiego prawa arbitrażowego
The aim of the article is to present legal effects of termination of arbitrator’s mandate. The main aspect of the problem is focused on the question whether in case of termination of arbitrator’s mandate truncated tribun...
Skuteczność zapisu na sąd polubowny a umowa przelewu wierzytelności w prawie polskim i włoskim
The subject of this paper is an effectiveness of the arbitration agreement in case of transfer of receivables in Polish and Italian law. Thus, an attempt was made to answer the question if – despite the lack of clear reg...
Arbitraż handlowy w oczach użytkowników – wyniki badań bezpośrednich
The present article presents results of the research study conducted between 2015 and 2016 under the name “Commercial arbitration in practice. Experience of the largest companies operating on the Polish market”. The stud...