Catterall and Herring classifications in assessing Perthes disease – inter- and intra-observer study
Journal Title: Ortopedia Traumatologia Rehabilitacja - Year 2004, Vol 6, Issue 5
Abstract
Background. The purpose of this study was to compare the inter-observer validity and intra-observer reliability of the Catterall and Herring classification systems used in assessing pathological changes in Perthes' disease.Material and methods. The material consisted in x-rays from 58 patients (12 girls and 46 boys, 63 hips, average age 6) treated conservatively or surgically. The x-rays were assessed by a board-certified orthopedist with 19 years of experience, an orthopedist just taking board exams with 5 years of experience, and a resident. For statistical analysis we used the weighted kappa coefficient and the percentage of agreement.Results. The majority of the cases were qualified to groups II and III, and the younger observers evaluated more severely. The least inter-observer validity in both classification systems occurred between the resident and the senior physician. When the material was divided into two age groups (younger and older than 6), the validity of the Catterall scheme was similar in both groups, while in the Herring classification there was greater inter-observer validity for the older children. The Herring system shows greater intra-observer reliability overall; in the two age groups, the Catterall system shows greater reliability in the younger children, and the Herring system in the older. Conclusions. The Catterall classification system shows less validity and reliability than the Herring system, especially in reference to children older than 6. The greatest difficulties in classification decisions occur between Catterall groups II and III.
Authors and Affiliations
Szymon Pietrzak, Marek Napiontek
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP56226
- DOI -
- Views 127
- Downloads 0
Terapia skojarzona Glukozaminą i Chondroityną w chorobie zwyrodnieniowej stawów w świetle najnowszych badań
Wyniki leczenia operacyjnego skolioz idiopatycznych metodą trójpłaszczyznowej korekcji ze spondylodezą
Wstęp. Metodę operacyjnej trójpłaszczyznowej korekcji skolioz wprowadził Cotrel w latach 80-tych XX wieku. W początkowym okresie, do korekcji i stabilizacji kręgosłupa wykorzystywano haki laminarne lub pedikularne, dwa p...
Treatment of Spasticity with Botulinum Toxin
Spasticity is a complex disorder characterized by a velocity-dependent increase in muscle tone associated with exaggerated deep tendon reflexes. It can be caused by numerous diffuse or focal cerebral and spinal pathologi...
Assessment of the Influence of Body Composition on Bone Mass in Children and Adolescents Based on a Functional Analysis of the Muscle-Bone Relationship
Background. The functional model of skeletal development considers the mechanical factor to be the most important skeletal modulant. The aim of the study was a functional analysis of the bone-muscle relationship in child...
„Contracture syndrome” in newborns and infants according to Prof. Hans Mau as an explanation of the „geography” and certain clinical features of idiopathic scoliosis
Background. Many malformations and dysfunctions of the skeletal system are connected with the „contracture syndrome” described by Prof. Hans Mau. The clinical features include plagiocephaly, torticollis, infantile scolio...