Чи може Громадська рада доброчесності бути відповідачем в адміністративному суді? / Can the Public Council for Virtue be a Defendant in Administrative Court?
Journal Title: Журнал східноєвропейського права - Year 2018, Vol 51, Issue
Abstract
The article is focused on determining the legal status of the Public Council for Virtue (PCV) and taken decisions. The author, on the basis of a grounded analysis, answers the question: whether the Public Council of Virtue is a subject of authoritative powers and whether its activity on providing conclusions about the inconsistency of a judge (candidate for a judge’s position) to the criteria for professional ethics and virtue is the authoritative administrative function. The author of the article has paid particular attention to the practical issue – whether such conclusions can be the subject matter for administrative appeal. Answers to the questions were provided through a systematic analysis of socio-political events, which led to the creation of the PCV, as well as different methods of interpretation of the relevant Articles of the law, were applied. It is this fact, and also the analysis of the purpose of including the PCV into this process and the procedure for its formation, provided by the law, made it possible to conclude that the PCV is not a subject of authoritative powers and does not perform any authoritative administrative function. The author of the article has proved that the PCV is an institution of civil society, which, regardless of the state and its agencies, participates in the procedure for the qualification of judges (candidates for a judge) and does not implement the powers of state authorities in terms of the qualification of judges either on a permanent or on a temporary basis. In this regard, it has been stressed that its opinion taken concerning a judge (candidate for a judge’s position) is not an administrative act (legal act of individual action), which, as a consequence, precludes the possibility of its appeal to an administrative court by a judge (candidate for a position of judge), in relation to which it was taken. Thus, the PCV cannot be the civil defendant in administrative courts.
Authors and Affiliations
Roman Melnyk
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP628558
- DOI -
- Views 145
- Downloads 0
Юридична відповідальність як гарантія реалізації прав, свобод та обов’язків особи у сфері новітніх технологій / Legal Responsibility as a Guarantee for the Exercise of Human Rights, Freedoms and Duties in the Sphere of New Technologies
The article examines the concept of legal liability as a guarantee of the realization of the rights, freedoms and duties of a person in the field of advanced technologies. The general and special features of legal respon...
Проблеми кримінального провадження щодо застосування примусових заходів медичного характеру / Issues of Criminal Proceedings Regarding Application of Compulsory Medical Measures
The author analyses the standards of criminal procedure and criminal law regulating compulsory medical measures. The article deals with the condition of legal regulation of compulsory medical measures, legislative proble...
Особливості продовження строку тримання під вартою в контексті Європейських стандартів / Peculiarities of Extension of Detention in the Context of European Standards
The article deals with provisions of criminal procedural legislation regarding extension of detention in the context of European standards. It has been noted that the issue of protection of the right to freedom and perso...
Ратифікація Стамбульської Конвенції як спосіб утвердження гендерної рівності в суспільстві: проблеми українського законодавства / Ratification of Istanbul Convention as a Way of Affirmation of Gender Equality in Society: Problems of Ukrainian Legislation
This article is devoted to the problem of woman rights, gender equality and gender discrimination in society. The author affirms that the disparity between women and men is a consequence of some historical processes, tra...
Основні напрямки державної політики у сфері вищої освіти / The Main Directions of the State Policy in Higher Education
The article deals with the main directions of the state policy in higher education. Organizational and legal mechanism for the state regulation of higher education transformations can be defined as a system of interrelat...