Cynicism in negotiation: When communication increases buyers’ skepticism

Journal Title: Judgment and Decision Making - Year 2014, Vol 9, Issue 3

Abstract

The economic literature on negotiation shows that strategic concerns can be a barrier to agreement, even when the buyer values the good more than the seller. Yet behavioral research demonstrates that human interaction can overcome these strategic concerns through communication. We show that there is also a downside of this human interaction: cynicism. Across two studies we focus on a seller-buyer interaction in which the buyer has uncertain knowledge about the goods for sale, but has a positive expected payoff from saying “yes” to the available transaction. Study 1 shows that most buyers accept offers made by computers, but that acceptance rates drop significantly when offers are made by human sellers who communicate directly with buyers. Study 2 clarifies that this effect results from allowing human sellers to communicate with buyers, and shows that such communication focuses the buyers’ attention on the seller’s trustworthiness. The mere situation of negotiated interaction increases buyers’ attention to the sellers’ self-serving motives and, consequently, buyers’ cynicism. Unaware of this downside of interaction, sellers actually prefer to have the opportunity to communicate with buyers.

Authors and Affiliations

Eyal Ert, Stephanie Creary and Max H. Bazerman

Keywords

Related Articles

Investigating intuitive and deliberate processes statistically: The multiple-measure maximum likelihood strategy classification method

One of the core challenges of decision research is to identify individuals’ decision strategies without influencing decision behavior by the method used. Bröder and Schiffer (2003) suggested a method to classify decision...

Boosting intelligence analysts’ judgment accuracy: What works, what fails?

A routine part of intelligence analysis is judging the probability of alternative hypotheses given available evidence. Intelligence organizations advise analysts to use intelligence-tradecraft methods such as Analysis of...

A hard to read font reduces the causality bias

Previous studies have demonstrated that fluency affects judgment and decision-making. The purpose of the present research was to investigate the effect of perceptual fluency in a causal learning task that usually induces...

It pays to be nice, but not really nice: Asymmetric reputations from prosociality across 7 countries

Cultures differ in many important ways, but one trait appears to be universally valued: prosociality. For one’s reputation, around the world, it pays to be nice to others. However, recent research with American participa...

Why do we overestimate others’ willingness to pay?

People typically overestimate how much others are prepared to pay for consumer goods and services. We investigated the extent to which latent beliefs about others’ affluence contribute to this overestimation. In Studies...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP678122
  • DOI -
  • Views 134
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Eyal Ert, Stephanie Creary and Max H. Bazerman (2014). Cynicism in negotiation: When communication increases buyers’ skepticism. Judgment and Decision Making, 9(3), -. https://europub.co.uk/articles/-A-678122