Does Early Egg Consumption Reduce Egg Allergy? Evidence from Randomised Controlled Trials
Journal Title: Biomedical Journal of Scientific & Technical Research (BJSTR) - Year 2019, Vol 14, Issue 2
Abstract
We refer to the six randomised controlled trials (RCTs) (PETIT; Natsume et al, HEAP; Bellach et al, BEAT; Tan et al and STEP; Palmer et al, EAT; Perkin et al, STAR; Palmer et al, published within the last five years. These trials reported on early egg introduction and risk of later egg sensitization and egg allergy at 12 months of age. Based on these trial results, it is clear that RCT results need to be critically appraised and interpreted. We found that the methodological differences among the studies may have influenced the study results. Therefore, critical interpretation of RCT results is required to understand the evidence. We refer to the six randomised controlled trials (RCTs) PETIT; Natsume et al. [1], HEAP; Bellach et al. [2], BEAT; Tan et al. [3] and STEP; Palmer et al. [4], EAT; Perkin et al. [5], STAR; Palmer et al. [6] published within the last five years. The trials reported on early egg introduction and risk of later egg sensitisation and allergy at 12 months of age. Although these six trials were very similar in several respects, we have concerns regarding the consistency of the findings. The Japanese PETIT trial was the only one to find a protective effect for egg allergy diagnosed using oral food challenge testing (OFC). Although the EAT and STAR trials concluded that early introduction of egg was protective against food allergy, neither showed good evidence on OFC testing. In terms of sensitisation, the BEAT trial found reduced sensitisation when whole egg was introduced to high risk infants. The STEP and HEAP found no protection for either sensitisation or food allergy. RCTs provide the highest level of evidence for a causal effect from an intervention [7]. However, belief in the RCT as a study design may lead to the results being accepted as unarguable evidence and a failure to critically appraise individual studies. This can lead to confusion when similar RCTs present conflicting results as is the case here. There are several methodological differences between the studies which may have influenced the results. PETIT was based on high risk children in Japan. The other studies on high allergy risk populations, the BEAT, STEP and STAR, all used Australian birth cohorts, and the allergy risk was defined differently. In the BEAT study, high risk was defined as any immediate family member (father, mother, older sibs) with food allergy, asthma, atopic eczema or allergic rhinitis. In STEP it was based on the “atopic status” of the mother only (medically diagnosed allergic disease with sensitisation to at least one common aero allergen), and results were adjusted for paternal allergic disease. The STAR trial recruited babies with severe eczema. In all three trials the intervention was similar (whole egg) and, all assessed the outcome at 12 months. However, the intervention timing and duration differed. In STAR and BEAT the intervention began at 4 and ended at 8 months with a duration of 4 months. In STEP, the intervention began at 4.5- 6 months continuing until 10 months with a variable duration of 4.5-6 months. They also differed with respect to analysis. Although both BEAT and STEP provided an intention-to-treat analysis, STEP adjusted for baseline factors which appeared different between the groups while BEAT controlled only for region of origin of parents. All 3 trials may have been underpowered (Table 1). The STEP trial which reportedly failed to reach the planned sample size was almost twice the sample size of BEAT and 10 times the size of STAR.
Authors and Affiliations
Nilakshi T Waidyatillake, John A Burgess, Caroline J lodge
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP594319
- DOI 10.26717/BJSTR.2019.14.002526
- Views 179
- Downloads 0
Why is Tinnitus so annoying?
Animals have their hearing as a warning system for the first line of defence, which raises the alert. In humans, except from the basic innate “animal” reactions, we have our thoughts and feelings, with our sentiments and...
Electroacupuncture Against Ethanol-Induced Gastric Ulcer in Rats: Effects on Gastric Contractility and in the Levels of TNF-α
Objective: To correlate the effects of the Electroacupuncture (EA) with the levels of TNF-α and the gastric contractility in both ulcerated and non-ulcerated control rats. Methods: Before the experiments, a magnetic mark...
Environmental and Health Safety Considerations of Nanotechnology: Nano Safety
Nanotechnologies are being spoken of as the driving force behind the new industrial rev-olution. The mass production of these nano materials and their applications mean a dramatic increase of workers dealing with Enginee...
Non-Coding RNAS and Steroidogenesis
Non-coding RNAs have retained a prominent role in regulating gene expression. They are RNA species that are not transcribed but functional participate in almost every aspect of cellular function. One of the triggers of t...
Medical Rice as a Whole Grain: A New Technological Advancement By Shaw Watanabe, For Prevention of Cardiometabolic Diseases and Dementia
Dementia has become a public health problem due to its impact on health and daily life. Major risk factors of dementia are cardiometabolic disease(CMDs), tobacco and lack of physical exercise. Western diet is an emerging...