Does Film Keep Anti-psychiatry Alive? Aesthetic Knowledge of Mental Illness and Institutions
Journal Title: Res Rhetorica - Year 2015, Vol 2, Issue 4
Abstract
The paper aims at evaluating contemporary films on psychiatry and their ‘knowledge’ of mental illness: How are mental illness and psychiatric institutions characterized rhetorically, and, are some psychiatric theories more present than others in the epistemological development of the fi lms? I will argue that the film ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’ (1975) by Milos Forman has an iconic status. It was based on a novel by Ken Kesey from 1961 and can be related to anti-psychiatry – a political movement as well as a psychiatric theory infl uenced by social constructivism, e.g. Michel Foucault. In The Divided Self (1960) by Ronald D. Laing and The Myth of Mental Illness (1962) by Thomas Szasz conventional psychiatric language was deconstructed. Thus, Szasz pleaded that mental illness did not exist and built up a new effective antipsychiatric language characterized by metaphors such as ‘prison’ and ‘prisoner’. These metaphors were given both presence (Perelman) and evidentia by Forman, who focused on clanking keys, bars, and belt fixation in the introduction to ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’. Also contemporary movies dealing with psychiatry, such as ‘Girl Interrupted’ (1999) by James Mangold, use the prison as a metaphor, probably as an intertextual reference to Forman’s film. In the end of the paper I will discuss the effect of these movies. Do they keep anti-psychiatry alive in the 21th century – even when the psychiatric theory as well as the political movement have lost influence?
Authors and Affiliations
Jette Barnholdt Hansen
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP192125
- DOI 10.17380/rr2015.4.3
- Views 128
- Downloads 0
Retoryka pytań w dyskursie sądowym
Artykuł podejmuje temat retoryki pytań w toku przesłuchiwania świadków na sali sądowej w kontekście polskiego prawodawstwa i praktyki postępowania sądowego. W szczególności przedmiotem analizy jest zastosowanie zabiegów...
Dobry doradca – piętnastowieczny portugalski traktat dydaktyczny. O poradach żywieniowych króla Edwarda
Dobry doradca (Leal Conselheiro) to traktat dydaktyczny napisany przez króla Edwarda (port. Dom Duarte), władcę Portugalii z dynastii Avis (1391–1438). Dzieło – podobnie jak inne utwory monarchy, któremu historiografowie...
Między chaosem a porządkiem – retoryczne zmagania z wybuchem I wojny światowej na łamach „Tygodnika Ilustrowanego”
Analiza tekstów opublikowanych w latach 1913-1914 (przed wybuchem I wojny światowej) w „Tygodniku Ilustrowanym” wskazuje, iż wydawane w Warszawie pismo koncentrowało swoją uwagę przed wszystkim na zachowaniu rozwagi i dy...
Teaching eloquence in a transition period: Hispanic handbooks of rhetoric in the first half of the nineteenth century
During the fi rst half of the nineteenth century, transformations in the mechanisms of political representation and the need to include new social sectors in the state apparatus led to the establishment of schools to inc...
Rhetorical Ambiguity and Political Leadership: Ethos and Negotiation in Fredrik Reinfeldt’s 2005 “Welcome to the New Moderates” Speech
This article explores how rhetorically ambiguous speech acts can work as preventive negotiations of potential confl ict within a political party and how such acts can affect the ethos of the leader. I show how rhetorical...