Rationality, Moral Motivation and Psychopathology
Journal Title: Studies in Global Ethics and Global Education - Year 2018, Vol 9, Issue
Abstract
Motivational internalism is a view according to which moral judgments are necessarily motivating. Rationalist internalism (RI) is the most popular version of this view; it limits internalism to people who are practically rational. Motivational internalism, including RI, has been criticized as being incompatible with research into certain personality disorder; in particular psychopathic personality and pathological personality which is the result of damage to the ventromedial prefrontal cortex (shortened to VM damage). In this paper, I argue that many of the features of psychopathic personality and of VM damage, which some philosophers interpreted as direct proof against internalism, should be understood as having an effect on the practical rationality of the patients. This means that these personality disorders cannot be used as counter examples to RI and can, in fact, be seen as supporting RI to some extent . I begin by describing RI. I then turn to I describing the phenomenon of psychopathic personality and VM damage and their philosophically relevant features. Finally I discuss whether the features characterizing psychopathy and VM damage influence the degree to which these disorders can serve as counterexamples to internalism of the rationalist variety.<br/><br/>
Authors and Affiliations
Karolina Jasser
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP424441
- DOI 10.5604/01.3001.0012.8147
- Views 91
- Downloads 0
Doradztwo zawodowe jako narzędzie realizacji zrównoważonego rozwoju kadry na lokalnym rynku pracy
In the presented article I am trying to describe the role of education and especially the role of career counselling in pursuing sustainable development education on the local labor market. Education is an extremely impo...
Peer Re-Production and an Extended Culture Industry. The Case of TV Content and Redistribution in Europeanizing and Globalizing Poland
Television content – mostly American productions – circulates among Polish Internet users. The article analyzes the increase in the scale of re-production of audiovisual content among large groups of the Polish network...
Folk High Schools as Institutions of Contemporary Regionalism: Chances and Threats to Traditional Culture in the Globalizing World
In the globalising reality we observe the increase of various antagonistic phenomena with completely contradictory tendencies, as integration and disintegration processes. Disputes and disagreements go on constantly and...
The Idea of a Universal Republic during the French Revolution
The idea of a universal republic as a global democratic state was deeply rooted in the enlightenment cosmopolitanism. Its conservative, anarchic and libertine version is represented by L. Ch. Fougeret de Montbron, the au...
“From Here to Globality:” A Pathological Local View
Building on the works dedicated to the center-periphery dependencies the paper proposes a project of the method and the research program focused around the local (provincial/semiprovincial) “pathologicalness” as a way of...