Glosa do wyroków Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 4 lipca 2012 r. (II GSK 917/11), z dnia 19 grudnia 2012 r. (II GSK 1823/11), z dnia 6 lutego 2013 r. (II GSK 2171/11)
Journal Title: Radca Prawny. Zeszyty naukowe - Year 2018, Vol 15, Issue 2
Abstract
The gloss refers to three judgments of the Supreme Administrative Court – of 4 July 2012 (court file No. II GSK 917/11), of 19 December 2012 (court file No. II GSK 1823/11), and of 6 February 2013 (court file No. II GSK 2171/11). In practical terms, however, it addresses an established opinion of the Court concerning administrative fines imposed pursuant to the provisions of Food Law (Article 40a of the Act on Commercial Quality of Agri-food Products). The Supreme Administrative Court views administrative liability as completely independent of guilt and even of perpetrator’s awareness of having committed an offence. Instead, it focuses solely on determining whether the conditions set out under Article 40a have been met. In the gloss, the author presents the case law of the Supreme Court, the Constitutional Court, the European Court of Human Rights, and the Court of Justice of the European Union regarding the topic researched. Based on the judgements, the author forms a critical opinion of Supreme Administrative Court’s views. Furthermore, the author argues for taking the perpetrators’ contribution to the offences committed into consideration in the process of imposing administrative fines.
Authors and Affiliations
Stanisław Witkowski
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP600951
- DOI -
- Views 78
- Downloads 0
Aksjologia postępowania dyscyplinarnego przeciwko sędziom i asesorom sądów powszechnych na tle niektórych regulacji działu II rozdział 3 ustawy z 27 lipca 2001 r. – prawo o sądach powszechnych
Amendments to the rules on disciplinary liability and disciplinary proceedings against judges and assistant judges [Polish: asesor sądowy] of common courts introduced in 2017, in conjunction with the recent practice of d...
Zwrot kosztów podróży strony na rozprawę przed sądem administracyjnym
The writing of this article was prompted by the judgments of administrative courts on the reimbursement of transportation expenses for attending a hearing incurred by a party to the proceedings, which represent a shift...
Refleksje o wybranych kompetencjach organu ochrony danych osobowych, przed i po 25 maja 2018 r.
The article addresses selected key issues concerning the powers of the authority for personal data protection (supervisory authority) in light of amendments introduced by way of the General Data Protection Regulation (GD...
Wpływ ostatecznego stwierdzenia nieważności warunków zabudowy z powodu ich ustalenia z rażącym naruszeniem prawa na obowiązywanie decyzji o udzieleniu pozwolenia na budowę
The article, entitled “The impact of the definitive declaration of invalidity of the land development conditions due to their determination with a flagrant violation of law on the validity of the building permit decision...
Glosa do wyroku Sądu Najwyższego sygn. II PK 264/15
The gloss assesses a current judgment handed down by the Supreme Court regarding alternative claims of employees (Article 45 of the Labour Code) arising under the provisions of the Labour Code in the event of defective n...