Glosa do wyroku Sądu Najwyższego sygn. II PK 264/15
Journal Title: Radca Prawny. Zeszyty naukowe - Year 2018, Vol 15, Issue 2
Abstract
The gloss assesses a current judgment handed down by the Supreme Court regarding alternative claims of employees (Article 45 of the Labour Code) arising under the provisions of the Labour Code in the event of defective notice or termination of employment. The authors put forward a critical view of the fourth thesis of the judgment (judgment of the Supreme Court of 8 December 2016, court file No. II PK 264/15). The gloss criticizes the Supreme Court’s position that partially conditions the effectiveness of an employee’s motion to have claims modified during proceedings before a labour court on the consent of the employer (when the modification is from a claim for damages to a claim for reinstatement). The arguments are supported by reference to current views expressed in both commentaries and case law, as well as the principles of labour law and the provisions of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland. The authors maintain that the judgment commented upon does not comply with the principles of labour law that lay down the requirement and the need to protect the employee and rule in favor of the employee’s rightful interests as the weaker party in the employment relationship.
Authors and Affiliations
Michał Żemojda, Marcin Skonieczny
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP600952
- DOI -
- Views 116
- Downloads 0
Zwrot kosztów podróży strony na rozprawę przed sądem administracyjnym
The writing of this article was prompted by the judgments of administrative courts on the reimbursement of transportation expenses for attending a hearing incurred by a party to the proceedings, which represent a shift...
Decyzja zamienna organu rentowego
In the proceedings within social insurance matters, the disability pension body, in particular The Social Insurance Institution (Polish: Zakład Ubezpieczeń Społecznych) and the President of the Agricultural Social Insura...
Zagadnienie tajemnicy zawodowej – analiza wybranych orzeczeń sądowych
The obligation to maintain professional secrecy is an indispensable element of practicing as legal adviser. Over the years, this issue has been the subject of numerous court judgments, interpretations, commentaries, and...
O żądaniach alternatywnych pracownika z art. 45 Kodeksu pracy
This article assesses the provisions of the Labour Code, including case law, on alternative claims of employees (Article 45 of the Labour Code) arising thereunder in the event of defective notice or termination of employ...
Wniosek o udzielenie sądowego zabezpieczenia poprzez wstrzymanie realizacji gwarancji bankowej należytego wykonania umowy – zasadność żądania w kontekście abstrakcyjnego charakteru gwarancji
The majority of opinions presented in the legal doctrine and case-law indicates that appending bank guarantees with the clauses “unconditional and irrevocable” and “at first demand” determines their abstract character. C...