Human Rights and Democracy: Marking the Boundaries of Community
Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2019, Vol 14, Issue 1
Abstract
Within the New World Order, there is one instance that is deemed responsible for the globalization in human rights, one court whose judgments are reportedly increasingly quoted by national courts all over the world and accepted by them: the European Court of Human Rights has been hailed as a ‘sort of world court of human rights’. At the level of general expressions and abstract language, human rights may, perhaps, be universal. But as soon as they turn into actual claims of rights, made in particular contexts to defend or criticize particular distributive choices, they become an effect of politics. There is no authoritative catalogue of rights that would be politically innocent: in an agnostic world, rights cannot be but legislative constructions, constantly referring back to alternative notions of the political good. In every social conflict, the claims of opposing sides may be portrayed as rights claims: my right of freedom against your right to security. The boundaries of freedom and security are drawn in accordance with cultural and political presumptions about the values that a good society prefers. And the process whereby an aspect of reality comes to be characterized in terms of rights is not dictated by any essential nature of the matter, either. It is a matter of political preference: only certain visions of the good life merit being accorded the level of protection that the classification as a ‘right’ entails. Moreover, the rights-language is imprecise and indeterminate in ways that defer back to policy concerns. Even a core right like the right to life has no meaning independent of the way it is interpreted by the relevant authorities. And, like all legal rules, human rights cover cases we did not wish to cover and leave uncovered cases that we think should have been covered Accordingly, rights must always be supplemented with exceptions. The scope or the criteria for the application of the exception are never clearly defined, however. Within the European Convention on Human Rights, the relationship between rights and the power to derogate from them is conditioned by what is deemed ‘necessary in a democratic society’ — a contextual and politically loaded criterion, surely. Rights, then, are a product of a political society. Given the ethos of international law (‘law against politics’), to say that human rights are the effect of politics, is nothing short of a scandal. But, let me emphasize from the start that I do not consider the banal administration of rights language a perversion or a scandal — quite the contrary. What I wish to assert is that the idea of human rights may bring emancipation precisely because it is the stuff of politics. This is what I shall do in my paper: using the case law of the European Court of Human Rights as my example, I shall look at the various ways to come to terms with bureaucratization and the possibilities of reserving the idea of human rights as a source of powerful critique of existing social institutions and practices. I also want to reflect on the consequences that the bureaucratization of human rights has on the current project for the New World Order, on the liberalism of certainties.
Authors and Affiliations
Jarna Petman
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP631729
- DOI 10.22096/HR.2019.111087.1149
- Views 111
- Downloads 0
Interreligious Communication: Celebrating Difference, Celebrating Understanding
The topic of interreligious communication is frequently defended as significant if different ethnic and religious groups are to coexist. Any society that consists of different religious groups has to establish some rules...
The Conservative Approach Toward Islamic Human Rights
Since the ratification of UDHR, Many steps have been passed, to universalize it, and religions and schools have been necessitated to take their position about it. Islamic trends and thinkers, also, have been considered...
An Assessment of Components of Human Rights Education in Highschool Curricula in Iran
The present study has been carried out on one of the most fundamental issues in the field of political pedagogy and curriculum as human rights education programs within schools. The main objective of this study consists...
Protection of the Children in Armed Conflicts (Approaches of International Law and Islamic Law)
The inauspicious phenomenon of war violates and threatens all rights of the children including right to life, right to live in the family, right to health, right to progress and right to education. According to the recen...
The Implicit Multicultural Discourse: Are Human Rights Treaty Bodies Supporting Multiculturalism?
Multiculturalism is an emerging notion within human rights discourse based on unity in diversity. It is usually admitted that human rights is in favor of difference and diversity, and this was clearly affirmed during the...