Particular forms of evaluation and assessment of judges: between exigency of a consolidated justice and violation of justice independence
Journal Title: Revista Institutului Național al Justiției - Year 2019, Vol 49, Issue 2
Abstract
The issue analyzed in the present paper refers to the fact if judges must be verified and/or assessed in their activity. In case of affirmative answer, we have to establish exigencies demanded for these verifications and/or assessments, to ensure the balance between the protection of public interest and judges’ private life. We emphasize the necessity to respect both the principle of separation and collaboration of powers and the independence of judges as individuals and of the Judiciary as a hole. We propose to develop within the Judicial Authority efficient mechanisms of intervention in the field of verification of office-holders (referring to judges and candidates for the position of judge) and in the field of assessment the professional integrity of judges. Simultaneously, we argue the indispensability of collaboration, in particular conditions, between the representatives of the Judiciary (The Superior Council of Magistracy, The Judicial Inspection) and the representatives of the executive power (The National Anticorruption Center, The Security and Intelligence Service, The National Integrity Authority), in order to exercise complex and qualitative verifications and/or assessments, avoiding threats to independence and the impartiality of magistrates.
Authors and Affiliations
Natalia Creciun
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP633952
- DOI -
- Views 90
- Downloads 0
The efficientisation of the mechanism for the application of the institution of mediation in criminal proceedings
The study proposed to present comparatively of the similarities between the institution of reconciliation and that of the mediation agreement, both based on the consent of the parties, respectively of the perpetrator (th...
Introductory concepts of the name of international treaties in contemporary international law
The object of this research is the scientific approach to the name of international treaties. The incomplete content of the provisions of Article 2 of the Vienna Convention on the law of international treaties, and the v...
The recognition and the effects of the decision authorising adoption in private international law
The realization of any kind of international adoption is conditioned by the existence of a institutionalized structure of international cooperation in the field of international adoption. The adoption can be considered f...
Criminal liability of legal entities according to the legislation of Ukraine and of the Republic of Moldova
The article investigates the peculiarities of the legal persons’ quasi-criminal liability, consisting in applying to them measures of a criminal nature, under the criminal law of Ukraine and the criminal liability of leg...
The reasonable information of mediator on the significant elements of the criminal case for mediation
The mediation procedure in criminal proceedings is subject to the criminal procedural norms of criminal law, corroborated with the rules of the mediation procedure, so that it also takes into account for the respect of t...