Risk communication with pictographs: The role of numeracy and graph processing

Journal Title: Judgment and Decision Making - Year 2011, Vol 6, Issue 3

Abstract

We conducted three studies to investigate how well pictographs communicate medical screening information to persons with higher and lower numeracy skills. In Study 1, we conducted a 2 (probability level: higher vs. lower) x 2 (reference information: yes vs. no) x 2 (subjective numeracy: higher vs. lower) between-subjects design. Persons with higher numeracy skills were influenced by probability level but not by reference information. Persons with lower numeracy tended to differentiate between a higher and a lower probability when there was no reference information. Study 2 consisted of interviews about the mental processing of pictographs. Higher numeracy was associated with counting the icons and relying on numbers depicted in the graph. Study 3 was an experiment with the same design as in Study 1, but, rather than using reference information, we varied the sequence of task type (counting first vs. non-counting first) to explore the role of the focus on numerical information. Persons with lower numeracy differentiated between higher and lower risk only when they were in the non-counting first condition. Task sequence did not influence the risk perceptions of persons with higher numeracy. In sum, our results suggest that pictographs may be useful for persons with higher and lower numeracy. However, these groups seem to process the graph differently. Persons with higher numeracy rely more on the numerical information depicted in the graph, whereas persons with lower numeracy seem to be confused when they are guided towards these numbers.

Authors and Affiliations

Rebecca Hess, Vivianne H. M. Visschers, and Michael Siegrist

Keywords

Related Articles

The influence of identifiability and singularity in moral decision making

There is an increased willingness to help identified individuals rather than non-identified, and the effect of identifiability is mainly present when a single individual rather than a group is presented. However, identif...

Prompting deliberation increases base-rate use

People often base judgments on stereotypes, even when contradictory base-rate information is provided. In a sample of 438 students from two state universities, we tested several hypotheses regarding why people would pref...

It’s personal: The effect of personal value on utilitarian moral judgments

We investigated whether the personal importance of objects influences utilitarian decision-making in which damaging property is necessary to produce an overall positive outcome. In Experiment 1, participants judged savin...

Choice-induced preference change and the free-choice paradigm: A clarification

Positive spreading of ratings or rankings in the classical free-choice paradigm is commonly taken to indicate choice-induced change in preferences and has motivated influential theories as cognitive dissonance theory and...

The opportunity-threat theory of decision-making under risk

A new theory of decision-making under risk, the Opportunity-Threat Theory is proposed. Analysis of risk into opportunity and threat components allows description of behavior as a combination of opportunity seeking and th...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP677797
  • DOI -
  • Views 141
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Rebecca Hess, Vivianne H. M. Visschers, and Michael Siegrist (2011). Risk communication with pictographs: The role of numeracy and graph processing. Judgment and Decision Making, 6(3), -. https://europub.co.uk/articles/-A-677797