St. Thomas Aquinas and John Locke on Natural Law
Journal Title: Studia Gilsoniana - Year 2017, Vol 6, Issue 2
Abstract
John Locke’s natural law theory has frequently been conceived as a continuation of the Thomistic tradition and as sound basis for human rights as universally binding. This paper concludes that this is not the case. Unlike Aquinas’ metaphysical realism, Locke’s empiricism and nominalism make it impossible for us to know our human nature, our exclusively human goods, and telos—thereby undermining the sound foundations of the exceptionless moral precepts of natural law. Whereas Aquinas defines the good as that which is perfective and fulfilling of human nature, Locke identifies the good with pleasure, which leads to subjectivism. While both Aquinas and Locke argue that God is the origin and foundation of the binding force of natural law, Locke’s voluntarism is incompatible with the ruling nature of law. Consequently, unlike Aquinas, Locke’s theory lacks the metaphysical foundations for universal human rights.
Authors and Affiliations
Ginna M. Pennance-Acevedo
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP252289
- DOI -
- Views 177
- Downloads 0
E-BOOK: Studia Gilsoniana 1
Studia Gilsoniana 1
EN TORNO A LA “METAFÍSICA DEL ÉXODO”
The article is a contribution to the academic study on the transformations undergone by the notion of being, as the object of metaphysics, in the history of philosophy. It is concerned with the expression “Metaphysics of...
Peirce, Sebeok, and the Semiotic Reformation on Contemporary Communications
Language in a broad sense becomes imperative for communication to ensue. Language considered as a system of signs and signification is achieved through a process involving sign relations, e.g. semiosis. Charles S. Peirce...
La plenitudo potestatis Papae según Egidio Romano
This article analyzes the relationship, according to Aegidius Romanus, between spiritual power and temporal power. From the point of view of the Augustinian author, the autonomy of the world or that of second causes, fol...
DIVINE POWER AND THE SPIRITUAL LIFE IN AQUINAS
The role of divine power in Aquinas’s spiritual doctrine has often been neglected in favor of a focus on the primacy of charity, the controlling virtue of spiritual progress. The tendency among some thinkers (e.g. Polkin...