The Ethical and Legal Aspects of Fee Splitting in Healthcare
Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2010, Vol 5, Issue 1
Abstract
Imposing unnecessary medical and healthcare costs upon patients is in direct contrast with patient rights and the spiritual and historical values of medical practice and it seriously undermines the honor regarding doctors and healthcare teams. All medical oaths and affidavits have repeatedly emphasized on the fact that medical teams and staff must take precedence over the patient’s rights and gains rather than their own. Such oaths clearly state that healthcare imposers must fulfill their duty regarding the patient’s physical and mental comfort. In the event of fee splitting, the medical staff not only neglect and undermine the medical affidavits but also seriously damage the hard gained doctor-patient trust and the historical honor of their profession. Within the law and justice system in practice in the Islamic Republic of Iran, fee splitting in considered unacceptable and illegal and fee splitters may be pursued by law. The same is true in different societies and most medical councils and accepted ethical codes and guidelines. It is clearly stated in the fifth paragraph of the medical affidavit vowed by all Iranian medical students and doctors that fee splitting is considered amoral and even illegal and that healthcare and medical practices are not to be used as a means of gathering wealth for oneself. All Islamic religious leaders have also questioned the lawfulness of money and wealth earned by fee splitting. The act of fee splitting is also recognized as unethical and unlawful in the guidelines and codes affected by universal medicine societies. چکیده تحمیل هزینه‌های غیر ضروری بر بیمار هم با حقوق اولیه بیماران و هم با شأن و شرافت ذاتـی و تاریخــی علم پزشکی و کادر پزشکی منافات دارد و همچنین همه سوگندنامه‌ها، پندنامه‌ها، منشورهای اخلاقی پزشکی و ... در طول تاریخ کادر پزشکی را ملتزم نموده‌اند که منافع بیمار را بر منافع خود مقدم بدارند و در تیمار و تسکین آلام بیماران حداکثر مساعی خود را به کار گیرند. در پدیده سهم‌خواری، متأسفانه پزشک و یا کادر پزشکی سهم خوار، برخلاف اصول بنیادین همه سوگندنامه‌های پزشکی از یک طرف و از طرف دیگر بر خلاف شأن و شرافت ذاتی حرفه پزشکی، به ضرر بیمار و به نفع خود، به سودجویی غیر اخلاقی می‌پردازد و اساس اعتماد پزشک ـ بیمار را به شدت مخدوش می‌نماید. مطابق نظامات دولتی و مقررات نظام پزشکی جمهوری اسلامی ایران نیز سهم‌خواری جزء موارد روشن قصور پزشکی بوده و قابل پیگرد سازمانی و حقوقی است، همچنانکه در بسیاری از کدهای اخلاقی ناظر بر عملکرد جامعه پزشکی و در اساسنامه انجمن‌های پزشکی و قوانین نظام پزشکی در جوامع مختلف نیز موضوع سهم‌خواری، رفتاری غیراخلاقی و بعضاً غیرقانونی در نظر گرفته شده و در پاراگراف پنجم سوگندنامه دانشجویان و پزشکان ایرانی هم بر پرهیز از آزمندی و نگاهبانی دانش پزشکی از سیم و زر تأکید شده است. فتاوی فقهی مراجع تقلید نیز وجوه حاصل از سهم‌خواری را غیرمشروع می‌دانند.در اساسنامه انجمن جهانی پزشکی در قسمت مربوط به تعارض منافع از سهم‌خواری یاد شده و این پدیده مذموم شمرده شده است.
Authors and Affiliations
Abdolhassan Kazemi, Mostafa Kazemi, Nejat Faizollahi, Sediar Ataalou, Mohammad Masoodinia
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP303417
- DOI -
- Views 122
- Downloads 0
Religiosity and Human Rights "A Comparative Study of the Relationship between Religiosity and Orientation to Human Rights among the Iranian Men and Women"
“Human rights” issue and its relationship with religious teachings is one of the controversial debates among thinkers. The aim of present study is to deal with the amount of urban educated Iranians orientation to human r...
Criminalization from Human Rights Perspective, the Demands of the Moral Right to Self-Determination
Human rights faces an obvious challenge concerning criminalization. On the one hand, putting emphasis on individual autonomy of human beings has blocked any attempt to impose any restrictions, the harm principle being th...
Corporal Punishment of Children: An Instance of the Challenge of Cultural Relativism and the Universality of Human Rights of Children
Today many countries have taken measures to recognize the values, principles, rules and norms of human rights, adopting appropriate mechanisms to ensure their implementation and monitoring through a set of documents, doc...
Right to Social Security in Human Rights Instruments and in International Labor Organization (with a glance at some Islamic Countries Practices)
The right to Social Security is one of the rights which appears in two important instruments of human rights—that is, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Th...
The Universal Islamic Declaration on Human Rights and the Problem of Inequalities of Rights between Men and Women
The Universal Islamic Declaration on Human Rights (the UIDHR) is the most important official replication to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (the UDHR) by Islamic countries, and based on that, it has been attemp...