НОРМАТИВНО-ПРАВОВЕ РЕГУЛЮВАННЯ ТА ПСИХОЛОГІЧНІ АСПЕКТИ ПРИЙНЯТТЯ СЛІДЧИМ СУДДЕЮ РІШЕННЯ ЩОДО НАДАННЯ ДОЗВОЛУ НА ПРОВЕДЕННЯ НЕГЛАСНИХ СЛІДЧИХ (РОЗШУКОВИХ) ДІЙ
Journal Title: Південноукраїнський правничий часопис - Year 2018, Vol 4, Issue 2
Abstract
The article researches the legal regulation of the participants’ activities in criminal proceedings during the consideration of the petition as for giving permission to carry out some secret investigations, taking into account the principles of the presumption of innocence and adversarial parties and analyzes the psychological aspects of the investigating judge’s decision to give permission to hold secret investigative actions. A great attention is paid to the fact that while checking the legitimacy, legality and justification of the investigative authorities’ need to obtain evidence by conducting secret investigative actions, the investigating judge should form his/her own opinion. At the same time, the doctrinal understanding of his/her own opinion as such a state of consciousness of the judge, when he/she considering the available evidence sufficient to address the question of the existence or absence of facts included in the subject of evidence, is confident in the correctness of his/her conclusion and is ready for practical action in accordance with the gained knowledge , also obliges to consider the depth of the investigation in such circumstances that should convince him/her in the possibility of giving permission to carry out secret investigative (search) action. The guideline for the content of an investigating judge’s decision to give permission to carry out secret investigators actions, and thus to list issues for which the investigating judge should form his/her own opinion, should serve as a list of circumstances that the law obliges to indicate, in the relevant, the petition of the investigator and the prosecutor (Part 2 of Article 248 of the CCP). That is, in the decision of the investigating judge, the judge’s assessment of all the circumstances which are in the petition of the investigator, the prosecutor, as from the point of view of their completeness (taking into account the requirements of Part 2 of Article 248 of the CPC), and in view of their motivation, reasonableness and persuasiveness in a particular situation. The expediency of involving the consideration of the petition for giving permission to carry out some secret investigations (searches) of a lawyer, who, according to the instructions of the Bar Association, will give a legal assessment to the arguments of the initiator of the restriction of the person’s rights as a representative of the community but not of a concrete person.
Authors and Affiliations
Ю. В. Меркулова, І. С. Казарян
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP608266
- DOI -
- Views 55
- Downloads 0
АПАРАТ УПРАВЛІННЯ ГАЛИЧИНОЮ В УМОВАХ УТВЕРДЖЕННЯ КОНСТИТУЦІЙНИХ НОРМ АВСТРО-УГОРЩИНИ
The article investigates the legal foundations of the formation and functioning of the administrative apparatus of management of Galicia during its period of being in the Habsburg Empire. The emphasis is on reforming the...
ЩОДО ВИЗНАЧЕННЯ ПОНЯТТЯ СПЕЦІАЛЬНОЇ ОПЕРАЦІЇ: ТЕОРЕТИКО-ПРАВОВИЙ АСПЕКТ
This scientific article examines the positions proposed by scientists regarding the definition of the concept of “special operation”, which are carried out by the bodies and subdivisions of the Ministry of Internal Affai...
ЮРИДИЧНА ВІДПОВІДАЛЬНІСТЬ ПОШТОВО-ТЕЛЕГРАФНИХ СЛУЖБОВЦІВ РОСІЙСЬКОЇ ІМПЕРІЇ У ДРУГІЙ ПОЛОВИНІ ХІХ – НА ПОЧАТКУ ХХ СТОЛІТТЯ
The types of punishments foreseed in the “Regulations on the penalties of criminals and corrected criminals” for the violation of the Postal Statute (postal and telegraphic) are highlighted. For disciplinary offences the...
ПРАВОВЕ РЕГУЛЮВАННЯ НОТАРІАЛЬНОЇ ДІЯЛЬНОСТІ НА ЗАХІДНОУКРАЇНСЬКИХ ЗЕМЛЯХ У СКЛАДІ ПОЛЬЩІ (1921–1939 РР.)
The article examines the legal field in which the notary activity was carried out on the western Ukrainian lands as a part of Poland during the interwar period. The empirical basis of the research constitutes the works o...
ОБСТАВИНИ, ЯКІ ВРАХОВУЮТЬСЯ СЛІДЧИМИ СУДДЯМИ ПІД ЧАС ОБРАННЯ ЗАПОБІЖНОГО ЗАХОДУ У ВИГЛЯДІ ТРИМАННЯ ПІД ВАРТОЮ
This article is devoted to the analysis of circumstances which should be taken into account by investigating judges in choosing measures of restrain in a form of detention. Scientific article provides an analysis of the...