ОБСТАВИНИ, ЯКІ ВРАХОВУЮТЬСЯ СЛІДЧИМИ СУДДЯМИ ПІД ЧАС ОБРАННЯ ЗАПОБІЖНОГО ЗАХОДУ У ВИГЛЯДІ ТРИМАННЯ ПІД ВАРТОЮ
Journal Title: Південноукраїнський правничий часопис - Year 2018, Vol 3, Issue
Abstract
This article is devoted to the analysis of circumstances which should be taken into account by investigating judges in choosing measures of restrain in a form of detention. Scientific article provides an analysis of the circumstances listed in Article 178 of the CPC, and it was proposed to divide all these circumstances into two groups: those circumstances which are connected with the commission of a criminal offense and those circumstances which are connected with a suspect himself. Authors also analyzed 230 rulings of investigating judges to enforce measure of restrain in a form of detention in period from 2014 to 2018 using IBM SPSS Statistic v. 23 with the determination of nominal scale according to relevant circumstances. According to the results of this analysis it was established that investigative judges in general do not comply with the requirements of Article 178 of the CPC in mandatory determination of all these circumstances. It has also been established that investigating judges can determine these circumstances only if relevant evidences have been submitted by the parties in criminal proceedings. In this case, as noted in article, in that cases investigating judges can gain access to such circumstances in some occasions (for example, when establishing the health status of a suspect on the basis of his appearance in accordance with Chapter 7 Article 206 of the CPC). Thus it was concluded that circumstances listed in Article 178 of the CCP require more thorough doctrinal analysis in order to formulate practical recommendations for investigating judges and courts in their practical application of the CPC.
Authors and Affiliations
О. О. Торбас, В. А. Касьянова
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP607939
- DOI -
- Views 62
- Downloads 0
ВІЙСЬКОВІ АДМІНІСТРАЦІЇ ЯК ТИМЧАСОВІ ДЕРЖАВНІ ОРГАНИ З ЕЛЕМЕНТАМИ ВІЙСЬКОВОЇ ОРГАНІЗАЦІЇ УПРАВЛІННЯ У СКЛАДІ СЕКТОРУ БЕЗПЕКИ Й ОБОРОНИ УКРАЇНИ
The article deals with the issue of the military administrations belonging to state bodies within the security and defense sector of Ukraine. Military administrations may be formed in territories where martial law is imp...
ІСТОРІЯ СТАНОВЛЕННЯ ТА РОЗВИТКУ ПОШУКОВОЇ ДІЯЛЬНОСТІ ОПЕРАТИВНИХ ПІДРОЗДІЛІВ
The article deals with the history of the formation of the search as a separate type of activity. Retrospective analysis of the search work in the law enforcement agencies allowed to distinguish the stages of its formati...
АДМІНІСТРАТИВНА ВІДПОВІДАЛЬНІСТЬ ЗА ВЧИНЕННЯ ДОМАШНЬОГО НАСИЛЬСТВА: ОСОБЛИВОСТІ ВПРОВАДЖЕННЯ НОВОГО ЗАКОНОДАВСТВА
The article is devoted to the study of the peculiarities of administrative responsibility for domestic violence on the basis of the analysis of legislation in the field of prevention and counteraction to domestic violenc...
ЗАКОННІ ПРИВАТНІ ІНТЕРЕСИ У ПОДАТКОВИХ ВІДНОСИНАХ ТА ЇХ ВІДМЕЖУВАННЯ ВІД ІНШИХ ІНТЕРЕСІВ ПЛАТНИКІВ ПОДАТКІВ
The article is devoted to analysis of the legal private interests of taxpayers, concretization of their content, delimitation from other private interests of taxpayers, including those that cause the appearance of abuses...
КОНТРОЛЬНА ПРАВОЗАСТОСОВНА ФОРМА РЕАЛІЗАЦІЇ ФУНКЦІЙ СУЧАСНОЇ ДЕРЖАВИ УКРАЇНА: ТЕОРЕТИЧНІ ПИТАННЯ
The article is devoted to the control of the law-enforcement form of the implementation of the functions of the modern state of Ukraine. Considered and generalized positions expressed in the literature on control, contro...